Man assaulted PC in hotel bust-up

A GRAYS man who crippled a policewoman when he fought to stop himself being arrested at a hotel has walked free from court.

John Hanly, 46, flipped during a row over plumbing while staying at the hotel in Gloucester and began yelling at staff.

When police were called to the Premier Inn Hotel in Barnwood, PC Catherine Fletcher suffered a spinal fracture as she and three other officers grappled to restrain and arrest the drunken dad-of-three.

Hanly, of Kingsley Walk, who had no previous convictions, admitted assaulting PC Fletcher with intent to resist.

Six months after the incident she is still walking with crutches and it could be three to four years before she fully recovers – if she ever does, Gloucester Crown Court was told.

Judge William Hart sentenced Hanly to 32 weeks in prison, suspended for 15 months, and placed him under a home curfew from 9pm to 6am on days when he is not working as a maintenance fitter.

The judge also ordered him to pay compensation of £7,500 to PC Fletcher, who is from Bristol.

Prosecutor Lisa Hennessy said the incident occurred while Hanly was staying at the hotel on March 22 and flooded his room when the bath overflowed when he left the plug in.

She said: “Staff were arranging to move him to another room when he demanded to know what else they were prepared to do for the inconvenience he had sustained in having to pack and change rooms.

“He was told he was not entitled to anything because it was his fault the room had flooded. Hanly then insisted the hotel plumbing was inadequate and demanded compensation.

“When it was pointed out that, in fact, the hotel should charge him for the damage rather than compensate him, he became confrontational.”

When police arrived, Hanly erupted again.

Mrs Hennessy said: “He began to rant and was shouting about sensors being fitted to plugs and demanding to know why two women had been sent as they knew nothing about plumbing!”

As cops tried to arrest Hanly for being drunk and disorderly, he began fighting with the police.

The court heard how he was a “strong individual” and put up a fierce struggle.

PC Fletcher was kneeling across his legs to stop him kicking out. He was struggling so forcefully that he managed to unbalance the officers and in the melee the other officers fell on her left leg.

Hanly told police he “probably had too much to drink” but said the police officers hadn't seen his point about the plumbing and he got frustrated.

He said he had not wanted to hurt anyone and he had resisted arrest because he did not want to be restrained.

Comments(6)

fletch12107 says...
11:19am Sat 20 Oct 12

I am struggling to understand this story. The defendant never left court unpunished by didn't get a custodial. The story also says that " PC Fletcher was kneeling across his legs to stop him kicking out. He was struggling so forcefully that he managed to unbalance the officers and in the melee the other officers fell on her left leg". So did the defendant "cripple" her or did the other officers falling on her cause her to be "crippled". Not very good journalism here I'm afraid.

Hawkeye1951 says...
1:57pm Mon 22 Oct 12

I wrote this report and I resent the suggestion that it's not very good journalism, Fletch!
We journalists say 'walked free' when someone is not sent to prison. He wasn't sent to prison .
She was crippled because of what he did - in law he is guilty of causing her injuries because his actions led to the damage to her leg. She wouldn't have been injured if it was not for him. Note, it's him who has been prosecuted, not the officers who fell onto their colleague as a result of his offending.

rogwj says...
9:43pm Mon 22 Oct 12

While I agree, Hawkeye1951, that thanks to the applicable law, the defendant was guilty, through his actions, of causing the injuries sustained by PC Fletcher, and there is a clue to this in that the court made a compensation order of £7500 in favour of Ms Fletcher, maybe this finer point, for the sake of clarity, could have been mentioned in the report. Fletch12107 is a frequent commentator here and generally I agree with his views, but maybe he was a little excessive in his criticism on this occasion.

fletch12107 says...
9:33am Tue 23 Oct 12

Hawkeye you journalists may say that he "walked free" and in journalistic circles that may mean that a custodial wasn't given but for the reader that may imply that someone was found not guilty.
You say in your article that a Grays man crippled PC Fletcher but nowhere in the article did you report how he crippled her but made reference to the fact that other officers fell on her legs during the struggle. I was trying to ascertain whether or not it was as a direct result of force by the Grays man that "crippled" her or by the officers falling on her.
A good story is one that gives the facts clearly and in a understandable fashion and I felt that this article left people wondering.

rogwj says...
11:00am Tue 23 Oct 12

Good point Fletch12107. I wondered the same and I Googled and read the reports in the Gloucester area papers. In each of these there are fuller and clearer reports, particularly following the pre-sentencing hearing that was in mid-September.

Thurrockbob says...
6:04am Wed 24 Oct 12

fletch12107 wrote:
Hawkeye you journalists may say that he "walked free" and in journalistic circles that may mean that a custodial wasn't given but for the reader that may imply that someone was found not guilty.
You say in your article that a Grays man crippled PC Fletcher but nowhere in the article did you report how he crippled her but made reference to the fact that other officers fell on her legs during the struggle. I was trying to ascertain whether or not it was as a direct result of force by the Grays man that "crippled" her or by the officers falling on her.
A good story is one that gives the facts clearly and in a understandable fashion and I felt that this article left people wondering.
Well said .... A half story is no story, it is about time some journalists gave ALL the facts not just snippets, and not just summarys. Hawkeye ...... If you want to make it in the world of journalism, tell the WHOLE story!

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree